On this page14 sections
All pricing and review data verified July 2026 unless otherwise noted. Pricing changes frequently; treat figures as "as-of" snapshots and confirm with vendors before purchasing.
TL;DR: The Verdict
#- Choose Lodgify if you are an individual host or small operator (roughly 1-20 properties) who wants transparent, published pricing, a genuinely strong direct-booking website builder, free onboarding, and simplicity. Per Capterra (July 2026), "Lodgify starts at $14/month for the Basic plan, with Starter at 26, Professional at 42, and Ultimate at 62; all include 0% booking fees and a free trial."
- Choose Guesty if you are a professional property manager or growing company (roughly 15-500+ listings) that needs deep automation, 60+ direct channel integrations, native trust accounting, an owner portal, an open API, and 24/7 phone support. It can also mean absorbing quote-only pricing, onboarding fees, add-on costs, and annual contracts.
- The single biggest tradeoff: Lodgify is cheaper, simpler, and better for building your own booking website. Guesty is more powerful, more scalable, and better for multi-owner operations, but its true cost is opaque and its contracts are rigid, with billing disputes a recurring, documented complaint.
Where the recommendation flips
Key Findings
#- Positioning: Lodgify is built for direct-booking-first independent hosts and small PMs. Guesty is an enterprise-grade operating system that scales from 1 to thousands of listings but is really designed for professional property management companies (PMCs).
- Pricing transparency is the sharpest contrast. Lodgify publishes all tiers. Guesty publishes only its "Lite" tier ($16/mo annual, 1-3 listings); its Pro (4-199 listings) and Enterprise (200+) tiers are quote-only, and none of its many add-ons carry published prices.
- Channels: Per Guesty's own channel-manager page, "Guesty's Channel Manager connects to 60+ booking channels... All connections are direct API integrations, not iCal feeds." Lodgify offers direct API to a small set (Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, Expedia, Google Vacation Rentals) plus iCal for the rest.
- Reviews: Both are well-rated on ease-of-use sites but carry a notable undercurrent of billing/contract complaints. It is worse and more structural for Guesty (auto-renewal, quote disputes, Guesty Shield overcharges), and centered on sync reliability and refund refusals for Lodgify.
- Support: Guesty runs a large 24/7 phone-supported team but complaints about escalation persist. Lodgify's onboarding is widely praised, but post-launch technical support draws criticism.
1. Company Background & Positioning
#Lodgify
#- Founded: 2012 in Barcelona, Spain, by Marco De Gregorio and Dennis Klett. Legal entity: Codebay Solutions SLU.
- HQ: Barcelona, Spain (Avenida Josep Tarradellas 20-30). Remote/hybrid team across ~6 continents, including a LATAM team in Buenos Aires supporting US time zones.
- Size: Over 330 employees (careers page says "+350 Lodgifiers," 60+ nationalities). Grew team ~58% in 2024 (130+ new hires).
- Funding: ~$37M total across 5 rounds (Tracxn $37.3M; CB Insights $36.91M). Largest raise was a $30M (≈€30M) Series B in November 2022 led by Octopus Ventures, with Bonsai Partners, Aldea Ventures, ICF, Intermedia, and Nauta Capital. No confirmed new equity round in 2025-2026.
- Ownership: Private, venture-backed. Investors include Octopus Ventures, Nauta Capital, Bonsai, Aldea, Seedcamp.
- Scale: Lodgify's own site states "over 100,000 properties managed with Lodgify." (Third-party estimates conflict: ITQlick ~5,000 customers/50,000 users; another review cites 12,000+ active properties; Lodgify does not publish an audited count.) Used by hosts in more than 100 countries.
- Leadership (2025-2026): Shaun Shirazian became CEO on February 18, 2025 (previously Chief Product Officer at Pipedrive), succeeding co-founder Dennis Klett, who moved to a non-executive board role. Joaquim Lechá (ex-Typeform) is Chairman. Co-founder Marco De Gregorio's role shifted toward Chief AI Officer. Gus Machado was appointed Chief Product & Design Officer (July 2025).
- Rebrand: Lodgify rebranded in 2025-2026 ("Lodgify 2.0"), launching new dynamic pricing (powered by Beyond), an AI Co-Host (beta), a ChatGPT direct-booking pilot, a free "Lodgify Direct" AI-built booking site, and a new "Basic" entry tier.
- Built for: Individual hosts and small-to-mid property managers (Lodgify's own comparison says "up to 30+ rentals"; it markets to 1-500+ but is thinnest for large operators).
Guesty
#- Founded: 2013 (first funding 2014) by twin brothers Amiad Soto (CEO) and Koby Soto. HQ in New York (with major R&D in Israel); operates in 100+ countries.
- Size: ~819 employees (Tracxn, mid-2025); an "industry-leading R&D team" (Guesty cites 250).
- Funding: ~$410M total across 7 rounds. Most recent: $130M Series F in April 2024 led by KKR with Inovia Capital, at a ~$900M valuation. A prior $170M round (2021/2022) came from Apax Digital, MSD Partners, and Sixth Street Growth. Guesty had signaled a possible IPO (originally targeted 2024, then potentially pushed to end of 2025).
- Acquisitions (consolidation strategy): MyVR and Your Porter in 2021 (Your Porter became "Guesty for Hosts," now "Guesty Lite"); YieldPlanet, Kigo, and HiRUM, all in 2022 (HiRUM added Australia/APAC and hotel/aparthotel inventory, and Kigo added Europe); StaySense (2023); Rentals United in 2024 (Barcelona-based channel distribution, expanding direct channels to ~60).
- Scale: Guesty states it is "the engine inside more than 500,000 properties across 100+ countries" (Dec 2025). Serves thousands of PMs.
- Built for: Professional property managers and PMCs. Guesty's sweet spot is 15-500+ listings. It now spans three products:
- Guesty Lite (1-3 listings), formerly Guesty for Hosts / Your Porter. A separate product with its own help center and codebase.
- Guesty Pro (4-199 listings): the full platform most mid-sized PMs evaluate.
- Guesty Enterprise (200+ / 500+ listings): large multi-brand portfolios.
Bottom line on positioning: Lodgify is a focused SMB/direct-booking tool. Guesty is a consolidation-driven enterprise platform that acquired its way into the small-host segment. The "Guesty Lite is a bolt-on" critique is fair. It was an acquisition (Your Porter) and remains architecturally distinct from Guesty Pro (two separate help centers), meaning growing from Lite to Pro is closer to a migration than an upgrade.
2. Pricing (verified July 2026)
#Lodgify: published, transparent
#Lodgify restructured plans in 2025. Current per-property tiers (Capterra, July 2026): Basic $14/mo, Starter $26/mo, Professional $42/mo, Ultimate $62/mo, "all include 0% booking fees and a free trial." Live contradiction to flag: several independent trackers (comparatifchannelmanager.fr, getpulsesignal.com) still report a +1.9% booking fee on the Starter tier as of July 2026. Confirm your specific tier's fee at signup. Annual billing saves ~20%, bi-yearly ~25%. 7-day free trial, no credit card, extendable on request. Billing in USD, EUR, or GBP. Free personalized onboarding on all plans.
| Plan | Entry price (per property) | Best for | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basic | $14/mo | 1 property | Listing sync + unified inbox; no full website builder |
| Starter | $26/mo (some trackers cite ~$16 annual/$23 monthly +1.9% fee) | up to 2 properties | Channel manager, website builder, booking engine |
| Professional | $42/mo | scaling (entry point for 3+) | Adds automation, Google Vacation Rentals |
| Ultimate | $62/mo | larger operations | Adds reporting, task/cleaning management, guest registration, owner statements, permissions |
Approximate Professional/Ultimate cost at scale (annual billing, per Truvi's pricing-slider data): 5 properties ≈ $69/$92; 10 ≈ $97/$129; 50 ≈ $289/$402; 100 ≈ $508/$718 per month.
Add-on costs: Smart locks, damage protection (via Safely), and dynamic pricing are listed as optional add-ons. SMS is a small extra. Payment processing via Stripe/PayPal (~2.9%) or Lodgify Payments.
Guesty: mostly quote-only
#Guesty's own pricing page contradicts itself. The price card shows Lite at $16/mo (annual) or $23/mo (monthly) for 1-3 listings, while the FAQ on the same page (captured live July 27, 2026) reads verbatim: "Guesty's price depends on the number of listings you manage and which features you'd like to add to your toolkit. We have packages that start from $9/month per listing." A pay-as-you-grow Lite option is confirmed by eviivo.com: "Guesty Lite (for 1-3 listings, from $9 per month plus 1% per-booking fee)." Pro (4-199) and Enterprise (200+) are quote-only, and no add-on carries a published price.
| Plan | Price | Listings | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lite (annual) | $16/mo | 1-3 | Published |
| Lite (monthly) | $23/mo | 1-3 | Published |
| Lite (pay-as-you-grow) | $9/mo per listing + 1% per booking | 1-3 | Published (eviivo) |
| "Packages start from" | $9/mo per listing | unspecified | Published but contradictory (FAQ) |
| Pro | Not published ("Get a quote") | 4-199 | Quote-only |
| Enterprise | Not published | 200+ | Quote-only |
Reported (unconfirmed) real-world costs: Independent operators/aggregators report Pro effective rates of roughly $40-72 per listing/month (some cite minimums starting ~$38/listing sliding down with volume; a few sources cite 2%-5% of booking revenue models); one-time onboarding/migration $300-$1,500; GuestyPay processing ~2.9% + $0.30 per direct transaction; owner-portal add-on ~$5-10/listing/mo; annual renewal increases of ~5%-8%. The median Guesty customer reportedly pays ~$400/year (CostBench, small-host skewed). None of these are confirmed by Guesty.
Unpriced add-on modules: Guesty Ultimate bundle ("save 40%"), PriceOptimizer (dynamic pricing), Damage Protection / Guesty Shield, Guesty Pay, Advanced Websites ($49/mo + 0.5% of direct gross booking volume per Lodgify's comparison; custom domain $15/mo connect or $25 purchase), LocksManager, Guest Communication Services, Guesty Capital. Google Vacation Rentals costs $4/listing unless you have an Advanced Website (and Lite users can't access it).
What each vendor will tell you before you talk to sales
Contract terms: Guesty upgrades are instant, but downgrades must wait until end of contract; contracts are typically annual with auto-renewal. This asymmetry, plus quote-only pricing, means the sizing decision at signature is the one that sticks.
Total cost of ownership by portfolio size (directional)
#Monthly cost as your portfolio grows
Top of each published/reported range, in USD per month.
| Listings | Lodgify (published) | Guesty (reported/quote) | Practical winner on cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1-2 | ~$14-26/mo total | Lite $16-23/mo | Roughly even; Lodgify includes website |
| 5 | ~$69-92/mo | ~$200-360/mo (Pro) | Lodgify |
| 20 | ~$150-250/mo | ~$800-1,400/mo + add-ons | Lodgify on price, Guesty on capability |
| 50 | ~$289-402/mo | ~$2,000-3,600/mo + add-ons | Lodgify cheaper; Guesty likely necessary functionally |
| 100 | ~$508-718/mo | quote (often $50-75/listing) | Depends on need for accounting/owner portal |
| 500+ | Lodgify not ideal | Enterprise quote | Guesty (Lodgify not built for this) |
3. Feature-by-Feature Comparison
#Channel manager
#Direct API channel connections
- Guesty: 60+ channels via direct two-way API (not iCal): Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, Expedia, Agoda, Google Vacation Rentals/Google Travel, TripAdvisor, Hopper, HomeToGo, Homes & Villas by Marriott Bonvoy, Plum Guide, Whimstay, Trip.com, Traveloka, Glamping Hub, Misterb&b, and many niche/regional channels; hundreds more via open API. Lite is limited to Airbnb, Booking.com, Vrbo only. Note: Expedia integration is per-listing linked, not account-level.
- Lodgify: Direct API to Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, Expedia, and Google Vacation Rentals; other/local channels via iCal. Preferred-partner status with major OTAs. Sync is reliable at small scale, but users report lag and occasional double-bookings above ~15 listings with frequent rate changes.
- Verdict: Guesty wins decisively on channel breadth and API depth. Lodgify is adequate for hosts on the big 3-4 OTAs.
Website builder & direct booking
#- Lodgify: Its standout feature. No-code builder, customizable templates, free custom domain, SEO-optimized, multilingual, booking widget for existing WordPress/Wix/Squarespace sites, and free Google Vacation Rentals on Professional/Ultimate. Lodgify's own comparison states its "websites are optimized for SEO, resulting in an average of 40% of bookings being made directly by customers."
- Guesty: Basic booking engine on all tiers; a real branded website (Advanced Websites) is a Pro/Enterprise paid add-on with minimal customization and extra fees. Lite has no website builder.
- Verdict: Lodgify wins clearly for direct-booking-first strategies.
Unified inbox & guest communication
#- Guesty: Unified inbox across Airbnb/Booking/Vrbo, email, SMS, WhatsApp (business-account constraints apply); native ReplyAI drafts tonally matched responses; internal notes; 24/7 guest communication services (paid add-on).
- Lodgify: Unified inbox across channels + direct site; WhatsApp; saved replies and automated responses; GPT-powered AI Assistant with "Improve/Suggest with AI." Lacks internal team notes in the inbox.
- Verdict: Roughly even for messaging; Guesty edges ahead on team collaboration and 24/7 coverage; Lodgify's AI is competitive and improving fast.
Payments
#- Guesty: GuestyPay (native, Pro/Enterprise), GuestyPay Protect fraud detection, Stripe on Lite; ~2.9% + $0.30 reported. Security deposits, chargeback tooling.
- Lodgify: Lodgify Payments (native), or Stripe/PayPal. Multi-currency, automated reminders, PCI compliant. Users note it can't directly charge Booking.com cancellation penalties.
Automation, tasks & operations
#- Guesty: Deep automation rules/triggers, robust task management with auto-assignment for cleaning/maintenance/inspections, staff/cleaner mobile access, native LocksManager. Best-in-class for operations-heavy teams.
- Lodgify: Automation tools and task management (cleaning/check-in staff app on Ultimate). Solid but less deep; some PM modules criticized as overpriced/underpowered.
- Verdict: Guesty wins for multi-person operations.
Owner portal, trust accounting & financial reporting
#- Guesty: Native owner portal, owner statements, trust accounting, commission splits, GuestyPay, automated 1099-MISC generation, and (Dec 2025) an AI Agent for revenue management. This is Guesty's real moat for management companies. Caveat: multiple reviewers call the trust-accounting/accounting module clunky, confusing, or in need of a third-party workaround.
- Lodgify: Owner statements available (Ultimate); QuickBooks/Xero/FreshBooks integrations. Reporting is criticized for not capturing cleaning/linen/maintenance costs, limiting margin visibility.
- Verdict: Guesty wins for multi-owner PMCs needing trust accounting, despite module gripes.
Revenue management / dynamic pricing
#- Guesty: Native PriceOptimizer (paid add-on) + AI Agent for Revenue Management; integrates PriceLabs, Beyond, Wheelhouse.
- Lodgify: New native dynamic pricing powered by Beyond (2025-2026); also integrates PriceLabs and Beyond.
Analytics & BI
#- Guesty: Most advanced, with a custom report builder, owner statements, BI dashboards, and free guest analytics.
- Lodgify: Solid baseline reporting; advanced reporting locked to Ultimate.
Guest experience & screening
#Both integrate guest screening/damage tools. Lodgify: Truvi (formerly Superhog), Chekin, native damage protection via Safely, guest registration in 18+ countries (Ultimate), guest app with guidebooks. Guesty: native damage protection (Guesty Shield), guest app, check-in flows; guidebook feature is weaker.
Multi-unit / hotel inventory
#- Guesty: Strong. Flexible inventory, room-types, aparthotels, hotels (bolstered by Kigo/HiRUM/YieldPlanet), group bookings.
- Lodgify: Multi-unit supported but not hotel-grade.
Mobile apps
#- Lodgify: Host app 4.7★ Google Play / 4.1★ App Store; separate PM app (Ultimate) for cleaners/agents; guest app with guidebooks.
- Guesty: App 3.2★ Google Play / 4.1★ App Store (notably lower Android rating); no guidebook feature.
API & developer ecosystem
#- Guesty: Full open, documented API + webhooks (Pro/Enterprise); 100-240+ marketplace integrations.
- Lodgify: ~20-40 integrations and a booking-engine API, but no full open API for custom development.
- Verdict: Guesty wins for developers/large tech stacks.
Smart locks & IoT
#- Guesty: Native LocksManager + RemoteLock/August etc.
- Lodgify: Integrations only (Lynx, Nuki, Chekin, Schlage). Guesty's own comparison (self-serving) claims Lodgify lacks integrated lock management.
Multi-language, tax & compliance
#Both support multi-currency/language. Lodgify supports EN/FR/DE/IT/PT/ES in-product and automates guest registration to authorities in 18+ countries. Guesty handles trust/tax compliance and channel-specific pricing/tax across regions.
Team permissions & white-label
#- Guesty: Granular roles/permissions, white-labeling (owner/guest portals), enterprise seat management.
- Lodgify: Permission management on Ultimate; more limited white-labeling.
AI in 2025-2026
#- Guesty: ReplyAI, ReviewSmart AI, AI listing descriptions, PriceOptimizer, and the first embedded AI Agent for Revenue Management (Dec 2025) leveraging 500,000+ properties of data; multi-agent AI roadmap. Shipped 333 features in 2025.
- Lodgify: AI Assistant (GPT-powered) for messaging, AI Co-Host (beta), ChatGPT direct-booking pilot, AI dynamic pricing (Beyond), AI listing/content generation.
4. Onboarding & Implementation
#- Lodgify: Free personalized onboarding on all plans (a specialist sets up account, connects listings, trains). Widely praised: comparable paid onboarding elsewhere can cost up to $700. Setup is fast (website "in minutes"); Lodgify Academy, help center, webinars. Migration support exists but has drawn serious complaints (a French user reported ~€2,000 in double-booking losses due to an unguided Airbnb migration where the calendar wasn't blocked first).
- Guesty: Guided onboarding on Lite/Pro; "enterprise-ready onboarding" on Enterprise. Reported one-time onboarding fees $300-$1,500 (unconfirmed by Guesty). Steeper learning curve: reviewers repeatedly note complexity and multi-week ramp, plus Guesty Academy/help centers (separate for Lite and Pro).
- Verdict: Lodgify wins on onboarding cost, speed, and simplicity; Guesty requires more time and money but suits complex operations.
5. Customer Support
#- Guesty: Large 24/7 team with phone coverage. Per Guesty's own blog: "Guesty has 24/7 phone support at every plan size, backed by a 230-person team" (vs. a Hostaway support team "around 60 people"). Dedicated CSMs/Technical Program Managers at higher tiers. Lite gets chat/email; Pro/Enterprise get phone. But: support quality is the second-most-common complaint after price. First-line reps follow scripts, complex/billing/integration issues require multi-tier escalation, and resolution can take days. Enterprise accounts report better experiences.
- Lodgify: 24/7 phone/chat/email on all plans; regional phone lines (US/Canada, UK, Australia, Spain, Italy); 90% CSAT claimed. Onboarding support is excellent, but a recurring complaint is that quality "drops to zero" once issues reach the technical team.
- Regional (APAC/Australia): Guesty has APAC presence via the HiRUM acquisition; Lodgify offers an Australia phone line. Both serve EU and US time zones.
6. Customer Reviews & Real User Experience
#Review-score table (as of July 2026)
#Review scores by platform
Axis starts at 3.0 to show the spread, not at zero.
| Platform | Lodgify | Guesty |
|---|---|---|
| Trustpilot | 4.8★ (~2,760-3,900 reviews) | 4.5★ (~1,000-1,430 reviews) |
| Capterra | 4.5★ (~1,282-1,311) | 4.4★ (~462-480) |
| Capterra sub-scores | Ease 4.4 · Support 4.6 · Features 4.4 · Value 4.3 | Ease 4.4 · Support 4.3 · Features 4.4 · Value 4.2 |
| G2 | ~4.2★ (56-66 reviews) | ~4.6★ (64-84 reviews) |
| GetApp | 4.5★ (~1,282) | 4.4★ (~337) |
| Guesty Lite (Capterra, ex-Your Porter) | N/A | 4.7★ (~547) |
| App Store / Google Play | 4.1★ / 4.7★ | 4.1★ / 3.2★ |
| PissedConsumer | 1.8★ (13 reviews, small sample) | N/A |
Note the small-sample skew: Guesty scores higher on G2 (a smaller, more technical audience), while Lodgify dominates on high-volume consumer sites like Trustpilot/Capterra. Many Lodgify and Guesty reviews are vendor-invited with incentives ("Vendor Referred, Incentive Offered"), which inflates positive volume on both.
Lodgify: common praise
#- Direct-booking website builder and channel centralization (users report 40-75% of bookings shifting to direct).
- Ease of use and time saved; strong free onboarding (specialists named repeatedly).
- Good value for single/small hosts; AI messaging praised.
Lodgify: common complaints
#- Channel sync reliability (Airbnb/Booking.com) is the most consistent negative theme, with double bookings and financial discrepancies at larger portfolios (one 150-unit operator reported Booking.com sync failures).
- Billing & cancellation: auto-renewal without warning, refusal of pro-rated refunds after cancellation, refund refusals after the 14-day window. BBB and PissedConsumer show billing-dispute patterns (small samples but consistent themes).
- Reporting gaps (no cleaning/linen/maintenance cost capture); PM modules and guest app called "nearly worthless" by some.
- Support escalation drops in quality once past onboarding.
Guesty: common praise
#Comprehensive one-stop platform; excellent automation and message templating; strong channel manager; named CSMs praised (Hazel, Alexandra, Or, etc.); frequent feature releases.
Guesty: common complaints
#- Cost and quote opacity is the #1 complaint.
- Billing disputes are recurring and structural: a BBB complaint documents being billed for 17 vs. 9 listings and charged $50 vs. contracted $45 for Guesty Shield ($2,564.96 in disputed charges); Trustpilot users report being charged before agreed start dates and multiple incorrect charges (one ~$700 CAD); "constant battle with billing."
- Auto-renewal / contract rigidity: annual auto-renewal "without clear communication," inability to downgrade mid-contract; a "gap between sales promises and the superseding contract."
- Bugs/glitches affecting daily operations; accounting/trust-accounting module "clunky"; API reliability issues with poorly announced updates.
- Support escalation slow for complex issues.
- Overkill for small hosts.
Switching stories
#- Guesty's own (vendor-supplied) study of 724 US PMs (<20 listings, 2022-2024) claims +17% revenue per listing and +24.6% portfolio growth after switching to Guesty from Lodgify/Hostaway/etc. Treat as marketing.
- Independent reviews and forums show movement in both directions: hosts leaving Guesty for Hospitable (simpler, cheaper messaging) after billing/contract frustration; and a Lodgify review noting a customer who came to Lodgify from Guesty citing channel-mapping issues. Consensus among independent operators: Lodgify for direct-booking small hosts, Guesty (or Hostaway) once you scale past ~15-20 units.
7. Strengths & Weaknesses: Honest Verdict
#Where Lodgify clearly wins: direct-booking website builder; pricing transparency; lower cost at every SMB size; free onboarding; ease of use; higher-volume positive review base; consumer app ratings.
Where Guesty clearly wins: channel breadth (60+ direct API); automation depth; trust accounting & owner portal; open API & integration marketplace; multi-unit/hotel inventory; enterprise scalability; 24/7 phone support infrastructure; native dynamic pricing + AI revenue agent.
Roughly equal: unified inbox/messaging; native dynamic pricing (both now Beyond-powered on Lodgify's side); guest screening via integrations; AI messaging assistants.
Deal-breakers:
- Lodgify: sync reliability at scale (15+ units); rigid refund policy; thin reporting; not built for 100+ multi-owner operations.
- Guesty: opaque quote-only pricing; onboarding fees; annual auto-renewal + no mid-contract downgrade; recurring billing disputes; overkill and overpriced for 1-5 listings.
8. Best-Fit Buyer Matrix
#| Buyer profile | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| 1-2 properties | Lodgify (or Hospitable/Guesty Lite if messaging-only) |
| 3-10 properties | Lodgify for direct-booking focus; Hostaway/Guesty if automation-heavy |
| 10-25 properties | Tossup: Lodgify on budget; Guesty/Hostaway if you need accounting/owner portal |
| 25-100 properties | Guesty (or Hostaway) |
| 100+ / enterprise / multi-brand | Guesty Enterprise |
| Individual host | Lodgify |
| Professional PM / management company (multi-owner) | Guesty (trust accounting, owner portal) |
| Co-host / small management | Lodgify or Hostaway |
| Hotel / aparthotel | Guesty (Kigo/HiRUM heritage) |
| Direct-booking-first strategy | Lodgify |
| OTA-heavy, max distribution | Guesty |
| Budget-conscious | Lodgify |
| Operations-heavy (cleaners/maintenance) | Guesty |
| Owners needing trust accounting/statements | Guesty |
| US market | Either |
| Europe | Either (both Barcelona-linked; Guesty via Kigo) |
| Australia/APAC | Guesty (HiRUM) |
| LATAM | Lodgify (Buenos Aires team) or Guesty |
9. Alternatives Worth Considering
#- Hostaway: the most-recommended scale alternative to both; 20,000+ PMs, ~4.8★ on Capterra/G2, deep automation, 200+ channels, strong support. Quote-only pricing. Often beats Lodgify on automation and Guesty on price/support. Commonly recommended instead of Guesty.
- Hospitable (ex-Smartbnb): best-in-class AI guest messaging, simple, cheap ($0 free tier, ~$29+/mo), published pricing. Best for Airbnb-heavy hosts. Commonly recommended instead of both for small hosts. Thin on accounting/owner statements.
- OwnerRez: top-rated (near 5★), excellent reporting/owner portal/accounting, US-focused, ~$40-88/mo, granular control but steeper setup. Best for finance-focused hosts. Strong owner statements.
- Smoobu: simple, affordable baseline for individual hosts.
- Uplisting, iGMS, Tokeet, Beds24: Beds24 is the budget/power-user pick (~$10/mo, highly configurable); iGMS strong automation; Uplisting clean multi-channel; Tokeet flexible.
- Escapia, Streamline, Track, Avantio: enterprise/vacation-rental-manager platforms competing with Guesty Enterprise, especially in the US (Streamline/Track) and Europe (Avantio).
10. Migration & Switching Considerations
#- Timeline: Budget 2-4 weeks per migration (listing rebuild, channel reconnection, template rewrites). Do not migrate during peak season.
- Risks: Airbnb/OTA re-linking can trigger disconnects; block calendars before migrating to avoid double bookings (a Lodgify migrant lost ~€2,000 by skipping this). Review history on direct sites doesn't port cleanly.
- Data portability: Export listing details, booking history, guest contacts, and financials before switching.
- Exit costs: Lodgify: annual plans may auto-renew; refunds often refused after 14 days; no pro-rating. Guesty: annual contracts with auto-renewal; downgrades wait until contract end; get onboarding fees and renewal escalators in writing before signing.
11. FAQ
#Is Guesty or Lodgify cheaper? Lodgify, at nearly every portfolio size, and its pricing is fully published ($14-62/mo per property). Guesty only publishes its $16/mo Lite tier; everything else is a sales quote.
Which is better for direct bookings? Lodgify. Its website builder is the category's strongest and includes free Google Vacation Rentals on higher tiers; Lodgify says these sites drive ~40% of bookings direct.
Which is better for large property managers? Guesty: trust accounting, owner portal, 60+ channels, open API, and enterprise scalability.
Does Lodgify charge booking fees? Capterra (July 2026) says all plans include 0% booking fees, but some independent trackers still cite a 1.9% fee on the Starter tier. Confirm at signup.
Does Guesty require a contract? Typically yes: annual with auto-renewal; you can upgrade anytime but can't downgrade until the term ends.
How many channels does each support? Guesty: 60+ direct API (plus hundreds via open API). Lodgify: ~5 direct API + iCal for others.
Is Guesty Lite the same as Guesty Pro? No. Lite (formerly Your Porter) is a separate, simpler product with its own help center; moving to Pro is effectively a migration.
Which has better support? Guesty has more infrastructure (24/7 phone across all tiers, 230-person team, CSMs); Lodgify has better onboarding. Both draw complaints about escalation of complex issues.
Which do Redditors/independent reviewers recommend? For 1-20 direct-booking-focused hosts, Lodgify or Hospitable; for scaling PMCs, Guesty or Hostaway.
Caveats
#- Pricing is a moving target. Guesty's Pro/Enterprise pricing and all add-ons are quote-only; the "$9 vs $16" contradiction is on Guesty's own page (verified July 27, 2026). Lodgify's tiers, prices, and even the Starter booking-fee question show live contradictions across sources. All figures are "as-of July 2026."
- Review scores vary by source and sample size. G2 samples are small (dozens); Trustpilot/Capterra are larger but include vendor-incentivized reviews on both sides. BBB/PissedConsumer samples are tiny but thematically consistent.
- Vendor claims are not independent. Guesty's "+17% revenue" and "500,000 properties," and Lodgify's "100,000 properties" and "40% direct bookings," are self-reported. Third-party customer/property counts for Lodgify conflict widely.
- Vendor comparison and revenue-boost content (including Guesty's "Guesty vs Lodgify" page, Lodgify's "Why Customers Choose Lodgify" page, and Hostaway's/Hospitable's comparison pages) is marketing and should be discounted accordingly.
Flat pricing, no contract, no sales call.
Host Port syncs your calendars with Airbnb, Booking.com and Vrbo and gives every listing a direct booking page. That part is free: unlimited listings, no card, no time limit. Two-way channel sync is $10 USD per listing per month, and it puts guest messages from your connected channels in one inbox.