All pricing and review data verified July 2026 unless otherwise noted. Pricing changes frequently; treat figures as "as-of" snapshots and confirm with vendors before purchasing.
#TL;DR: The Verdict
- Choose Lodgify if you are an individual host or small operator (roughly 1-20 properties) who wants transparent, published pricing, a genuinely strong direct-booking website builder, free onboarding, and simplicity. Per Capterra (July 2026), "Lodgify starts at $14/month for the Basic plan, with Starter at 26, Professional at 42, and Ultimate at 62; all include 0% booking fees and a free trial."
- Choose Guesty if you are a professional property manager or growing company (roughly 15-500+ listings) that needs deep automation, 60+ direct channel integrations, native trust accounting, an owner portal, an open API, and 24/7 phone support. It can also mean absorbing quote-only pricing, onboarding fees, add-on costs, and annual contracts.
- The single biggest tradeoff: Lodgify is cheaper, simpler, and better for building your own booking website. Guesty is more powerful, more scalable, and better for multi-owner operations, but its true cost is opaque and its contracts are rigid, with billing disputes a recurring, documented complaint.
Where the recommendation flips
#Key Findings
- Positioning: Lodgify is built for direct-booking-first independent hosts and small PMs. Guesty is an enterprise-grade operating system that scales from 1 to thousands of listings but is really designed for professional property management companies (PMCs).
- Pricing transparency is the sharpest contrast. Lodgify publishes all tiers. Guesty publishes only its "Lite" tier ($16/mo annual, 1-3 listings); its Pro (4-199 listings) and Enterprise (200+) tiers are quote-only, and none of its many add-ons carry published prices.
- Channels: Per Guesty's own channel-manager page, "Guesty's Channel Manager connects to 60+ booking channels... All connections are direct API integrations, not iCal feeds." Lodgify offers direct API to a small set (Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, Expedia, Google Vacation Rentals) plus iCal for the rest.
- Reviews: Both are well-rated on ease-of-use sites but carry a notable undercurrent of billing/contract complaints. It is worse and more structural for Guesty (auto-renewal, quote disputes, Guesty Shield overcharges), and centered on sync reliability and refund refusals for Lodgify.
- Support: Guesty runs a large 24/7 phone-supported team but complaints about escalation persist. Lodgify's onboarding is widely praised, but post-launch technical support draws criticism.
#1. Company Background & Positioning
#Lodgify
- Founded: 2012 in Barcelona, Spain, by Marco De Gregorio and Dennis Klett. Legal entity: Codebay Solutions SLU.
- HQ: Barcelona, Spain (Avenida Josep Tarradellas 20-30). Remote/hybrid team across ~6 continents, including a LATAM team in Buenos Aires supporting US time zones.
- Size: Over 330 employees (careers page says "+350 Lodgifiers," 60+ nationalities). Grew team ~58% in 2024 (130+ new hires).
- Funding: ~$37M total across 5 rounds (Tracxn $37.3M; CB Insights $36.91M). Largest raise was a $30M (≈€30M) Series B in November 2022 led by Octopus Ventures, with Bonsai Partners, Aldea Ventures, ICF, Intermedia, and Nauta Capital. No confirmed new equity round in 2025-2026.
- Ownership: Private, venture-backed. Investors include Octopus Ventures, Nauta Capital, Bonsai, Aldea, Seedcamp.
- Scale: Lodgify's own site states "over 100,000 properties managed with Lodgify." (Third-party estimates conflict: ITQlick ~5,000 customers/50,000 users; another review cites 12,000+ active properties; Lodgify does not publish an audited count.) Used by hosts in more than 100 countries.
- Leadership (2025-2026): Shaun Shirazian became CEO on February 18, 2025 (previously Chief Product Officer at Pipedrive), succeeding co-founder Dennis Klett, who moved to a non-executive board role. Joaquim Lechá (ex-Typeform) is Chairman. Co-founder Marco De Gregorio's role shifted toward Chief AI Officer. Gus Machado was appointed Chief Product & Design Officer (July 2025).
- Rebrand: Lodgify rebranded in 2025-2026 ("Lodgify 2.0"), launching new dynamic pricing (powered by Beyond), an AI Co-Host (beta), a ChatGPT direct-booking pilot, a free "Lodgify Direct" AI-built booking site, and a new "Basic" entry tier.
- Built for: Individual hosts and small-to-mid property managers (Lodgify's own comparison says "up to 30+ rentals"; it markets to 1-500+ but is thinnest for large operators).
#Guesty
- Founded: 2013 (first funding 2014) by twin brothers Amiad Soto (CEO) and Koby Soto. HQ in New York (with major R&D in Israel); operates in 100+ countries.
- Size: ~819 employees (Tracxn, mid-2025); an "industry-leading R&D team" (Guesty cites 250).
- Funding: ~$410M total across 7 rounds. Most recent: $130M Series F in April 2024 led by KKR with Inovia Capital, at a ~$900M valuation. A prior $170M round (2021/2022) came from Apax Digital, MSD Partners, and Sixth Street Growth. Guesty had signaled a possible IPO (originally targeted 2024, then potentially pushed to end of 2025).
- Acquisitions (consolidation strategy): MyVR and Your Porter in 2021 (Your Porter became "Guesty for Hosts," now "Guesty Lite"); YieldPlanet, Kigo, and HiRUM, all in 2022 (HiRUM added Australia/APAC and hotel/aparthotel inventory, and Kigo added Europe); StaySense (2023); Rentals United in 2024 (Barcelona-based channel distribution, expanding direct channels to ~60).
- Scale: Guesty states it is "the engine inside more than 500,000 properties across 100+ countries" (Dec 2025). Serves thousands of PMs.
- Built for: Professional property managers and PMCs. Guesty's sweet spot is 15-500+ listings. It now spans three products:
- Guesty Lite (1-3 listings), formerly Guesty for Hosts / Your Porter. A separate product with its own help center and codebase.
- Guesty Pro (4-199 listings): the full platform most mid-sized PMs evaluate.
- Guesty Enterprise (200+ / 500+ listings): large multi-brand portfolios.
Bottom line on positioning: Lodgify is a focused SMB/direct-booking tool. Guesty is a consolidation-driven enterprise platform that acquired its way into the small-host segment. The "Guesty Lite is a bolt-on" critique is fair. It was an acquisition (Your Porter) and remains architecturally distinct from Guesty Pro (two separate help centers), meaning growing from Lite to Pro is closer to a migration than an upgrade.
#2. Pricing (verified July 2026)
#Lodgify: published, transparent
Lodgify restructured plans in 2025. Current per-property tiers (Capterra, July 2026): Basic $14/mo, Starter $26/mo, Professional $42/mo, Ultimate $62/mo, "all include 0% booking fees and a free trial." Live contradiction to flag: several independent trackers (comparatifchannelmanager.fr, getpulsesignal.com) still report a +1.9% booking fee on the Starter tier as of July 2026. Confirm your specific tier's fee at signup. Annual billing saves ~20%, bi-yearly ~25%. 7-day free trial, no credit card, extendable on request. Billing in USD, EUR, or GBP. Free personalized onboarding on all plans.
| Plan | Entry price (per property) | Best for | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basic | $14/mo | 1 property | Listing sync + unified inbox; no full website builder |
| Starter | $26/mo (some trackers cite ~$16 annual/$23 monthly +1.9% fee) | up to 2 properties | Channel manager, website builder, booking engine |
| Professional | $42/mo | scaling (entry point for 3+) | Adds automation, Google Vacation Rentals |
| Ultimate | $62/mo | larger operations | Adds reporting, task/cleaning management, guest registration, owner statements, permissions |
Approximate Professional/Ultimate cost at scale (annual billing, per Truvi's pricing-slider data): 5 properties ≈ $69/$92; 10 ≈ $97/$129; 50 ≈ $289/$402; 100 ≈ $508/$718 per month.
Add-on costs: Smart locks, damage protection (via Safely), and dynamic pricing are listed as optional add-ons. SMS is a small extra. Payment processing via Stripe/PayPal (~2.9%) or Lodgify Payments.
#Guesty: mostly quote-only
Guesty's own pricing page contradicts itself. The price card shows Lite at $16/mo (annual) or $23/mo (monthly) for 1-3 listings, while the FAQ on the same page (captured live July 27, 2026) reads verbatim: "Guesty's price depends on the number of listings you manage and which features you'd like to add to your toolkit. We have packages that start from $9/month per listing." A pay-as-you-grow Lite option is confirmed by eviivo.com: "Guesty Lite (for 1-3 listings, from $9 per month plus 1% per-booking fee)." Pro (4-199) and Enterprise (200+) are quote-only, and no add-on carries a published price.
| Plan | Price | Listings | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lite (annual) | $16/mo | 1-3 | Published |
| Lite (monthly) | $23/mo | 1-3 | Published |
| Lite (pay-as-you-grow) | $9/mo per listing + 1% per booking | 1-3 | Published (eviivo) |
| "Packages start from" | $9/mo per listing | unspecified | Published but contradictory (FAQ) |
| Pro | Not published ("Get a quote") | 4-199 | Quote-only |
| Enterprise | Not published | 200+ | Quote-only |
Reported (unconfirmed) real-world costs: Independent operators/aggregators report Pro effective rates of roughly $40-72 per listing/month (some cite minimums starting ~$38/listing sliding down with volume; a few sources cite 2%-5% of booking revenue models); one-time onboarding/migration $300-$1,500; GuestyPay processing ~2.9% + $0.30 per direct transaction; owner-portal add-on ~$5-10/listing/mo; annual renewal increases of ~5%-8%. The median Guesty customer reportedly pays ~$400/year (CostBench, small-host skewed). None of these are confirmed by Guesty.
Unpriced add-on modules: Guesty Ultimate bundle ("save 40%"), PriceOptimizer (dynamic pricing), Damage Protection / Guesty Shield, Guesty Pay, Advanced Websites ($49/mo + 0.5% of direct gross booking volume per Lodgify's comparison; custom domain $15/mo connect or $25 purchase), LocksManager, Guest Communication Services, Guesty Capital. Google Vacation Rentals costs $4/listing unless you have an Advanced Website (and Lite users can't access it).
What each vendor will tell you before you talk to sales
Contract terms: Guesty upgrades are instant, but downgrades must wait until end of contract; contracts are typically annual with auto-renewal. This asymmetry, plus quote-only pricing, means the sizing decision at signature is the one that sticks.
#Total cost of ownership by portfolio size (directional)
Monthly cost as your portfolio grows
Top of each published/reported range, in USD per month.
| Listings | Lodgify (published) | Guesty (reported/quote) | Practical winner on cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1-2 | ~$14-26/mo total | Lite $16-23/mo | Roughly even; Lodgify includes website |
| 5 | ~$69-92/mo | ~$200-360/mo (Pro) | Lodgify |
| 20 | ~$150-250/mo | ~$800-1,400/mo + add-ons | Lodgify on price, Guesty on capability |
| 50 | ~$289-402/mo | ~$2,000-3,600/mo + add-ons | Lodgify cheaper; Guesty likely necessary functionally |
| 100 | ~$508-718/mo | quote (often $50-75/listing) | Depends on need for accounting/owner portal |
| 500+ | Lodgify not ideal | Enterprise quote | Guesty (Lodgify not built for this) |
#3. Feature-by-Feature Comparison
#Channel manager
Direct API channel connections
- Guesty: 60+ channels via direct two-way API (not iCal): Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, Expedia, Agoda, Google Vacation Rentals/Google Travel, TripAdvisor, Hopper, HomeToGo, Homes & Villas by Marriott Bonvoy, Plum Guide, Whimstay, Trip.com, Traveloka, Glamping Hub, Misterb&b, and many niche/regional channels; hundreds more via open API. Lite is limited to Airbnb, Booking.com, Vrbo only. Note: Expedia integration is per-listing linked, not account-level.
- Lodgify: Direct API to Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, Expedia, and Google Vacation Rentals; other/local channels via iCal. Preferred-partner status with major OTAs. Sync is reliable at small scale, but users report lag and occasional double-bookings above ~15 listings with frequent rate changes.
- Verdict: Guesty wins decisively on channel breadth and API depth. Lodgify is adequate for hosts on the big 3-4 OTAs.
#Website builder & direct booking
- Lodgify: Its standout feature. No-code builder, customizable templates, free custom domain, SEO-optimized, multilingual, booking widget for existing WordPress/Wix/Squarespace sites, and free Google Vacation Rentals on Professional/Ultimate. Lodgify's own comparison states its "websites are optimized for SEO, resulting in an average of 40% of bookings being made directly by customers."
- Guesty: Basic booking engine on all tiers; a real branded website (Advanced Websites) is a Pro/Enterprise paid add-on with minimal customization and extra fees. Lite has no website builder.
- Verdict: Lodgify wins clearly for direct-booking-first strategies.
#Unified inbox & guest communication
- Guesty: Unified inbox across Airbnb/Booking/Vrbo, email, SMS, WhatsApp (business-account constraints apply); native ReplyAI drafts tonally matched responses; internal notes; 24/7 guest communication services (paid add-on).
- Lodgify: Unified inbox across channels + direct site; WhatsApp; saved replies and automated responses; GPT-powered AI Assistant with "Improve/Suggest with AI." Lacks internal team notes in the inbox.
- Verdict: Roughly even for messaging; Guesty edges ahead on team collaboration and 24/7 coverage; Lodgify's AI is competitive and improving fast.
#Payments
- Guesty: GuestyPay (native, Pro/Enterprise), GuestyPay Protect fraud detection, Stripe on Lite; ~2.9% + $0.30 reported. Security deposits, chargeback tooling.
- Lodgify: Lodgify Payments (native), or Stripe/PayPal. Multi-currency, automated reminders, PCI compliant. Users note it can't directly charge Booking.com cancellation penalties.
#Automation, tasks & operations
- Guesty: Deep automation rules/triggers, robust task management with auto-assignment for cleaning/maintenance/inspections, staff/cleaner mobile access, native LocksManager. Best-in-class for operations-heavy teams.
- Lodgify: Automation tools and task management (cleaning/check-in staff app on Ultimate). Solid but less deep; some PM modules criticized as overpriced/underpowered.
- Verdict: Guesty wins for multi-person operations.
#Owner portal, trust accounting & financial reporting
- Guesty: Native owner portal, owner statements, trust accounting, commission splits, GuestyPay, automated 1099-MISC generation, and (Dec 2025) an AI Agent for revenue management. This is Guesty's real moat for management companies. Caveat: multiple reviewers call the trust-accounting/accounting module clunky, confusing, or in need of a third-party workaround.
- Lodgify: Owner statements available (Ultimate); QuickBooks/Xero/FreshBooks integrations. Reporting is criticized for not capturing cleaning/linen/maintenance costs, limiting margin visibility.
- Verdict: Guesty wins for multi-owner PMCs needing trust accounting, despite module gripes.
#Revenue management / dynamic pricing
- Guesty: Native PriceOptimizer (paid add-on) + AI Agent for Revenue Management; integrates PriceLabs, Beyond, Wheelhouse.
- Lodgify: New native dynamic pricing powered by Beyond (2025-2026); also integrates PriceLabs and Beyond.
#Analytics & BI
- Guesty: Most advanced, with a custom report builder, owner statements, BI dashboards, and free guest analytics.
- Lodgify: Solid baseline reporting; advanced reporting locked to Ultimate.
#Guest experience & screening
Both integrate guest screening/damage tools. Lodgify: Truvi (formerly Superhog), Chekin, native damage protection via Safely, guest registration in 18+ countries (Ultimate), guest app with guidebooks. Guesty: native damage protection (Guesty Shield), guest app, check-in flows; guidebook feature is weaker.
#Multi-unit / hotel inventory
- Guesty: Strong. Flexible inventory, room-types, aparthotels, hotels (bolstered by Kigo/HiRUM/YieldPlanet), group bookings.
- Lodgify: Multi-unit supported but not hotel-grade.
#Mobile apps
- Lodgify: Host app 4.7★ Google Play / 4.1★ App Store; separate PM app (Ultimate) for cleaners/agents; guest app with guidebooks.
- Guesty: App 3.2★ Google Play / 4.1★ App Store (notably lower Android rating); no guidebook feature.
#API & developer ecosystem
- Guesty: Full open, documented API + webhooks (Pro/Enterprise); 100-240+ marketplace integrations.
- Lodgify: ~20-40 integrations and a booking-engine API, but no full open API for custom development.
- Verdict: Guesty wins for developers/large tech stacks.
#Smart locks & IoT
- Guesty: Native LocksManager + RemoteLock/August etc.
- Lodgify: Integrations only (Lynx, Nuki, Chekin, Schlage). Guesty's own comparison (self-serving) claims Lodgify lacks integrated lock management.
#Multi-language, tax & compliance
Both support multi-currency/language. Lodgify supports EN/FR/DE/IT/PT/ES in-product and automates guest registration to authorities in 18+ countries. Guesty handles trust/tax compliance and channel-specific pricing/tax across regions.
#Team permissions & white-label
- Guesty: Granular roles/permissions, white-labeling (owner/guest portals), enterprise seat management.
- Lodgify: Permission management on Ultimate; more limited white-labeling.
#AI in 2025-2026
- Guesty: ReplyAI, ReviewSmart AI, AI listing descriptions, PriceOptimizer, and the first embedded AI Agent for Revenue Management (Dec 2025) leveraging 500,000+ properties of data; multi-agent AI roadmap. Shipped 333 features in 2025.
- Lodgify: AI Assistant (GPT-powered) for messaging, AI Co-Host (beta), ChatGPT direct-booking pilot, AI dynamic pricing (Beyond), AI listing/content generation.
#4. Onboarding & Implementation
- Lodgify: Free personalized onboarding on all plans (a specialist sets up account, connects listings, trains). Widely praised: comparable paid onboarding elsewhere can cost up to $700. Setup is fast (website "in minutes"); Lodgify Academy, help center, webinars. Migration support exists but has drawn serious complaints (a French user reported ~€2,000 in double-booking losses due to an unguided Airbnb migration where the calendar wasn't blocked first).
- Guesty: Guided onboarding on Lite/Pro; "enterprise-ready onboarding" on Enterprise. Reported one-time onboarding fees $300-$1,500 (unconfirmed by Guesty). Steeper learning curve: reviewers repeatedly note complexity and multi-week ramp, plus Guesty Academy/help centers (separate for Lite and Pro).
- Verdict: Lodgify wins on onboarding cost, speed, and simplicity; Guesty requires more time and money but suits complex operations.
#5. Customer Support
- Guesty: Large 24/7 team with phone coverage. Per Guesty's own blog: "Guesty has 24/7 phone support at every plan size, backed by a 230-person team" (vs. a Hostaway support team "around 60 people"). Dedicated CSMs/Technical Program Managers at higher tiers. Lite gets chat/email; Pro/Enterprise get phone. But: support quality is the second-most-common complaint after price. First-line reps follow scripts, complex/billing/integration issues require multi-tier escalation, and resolution can take days. Enterprise accounts report better experiences.
- Lodgify: 24/7 phone/chat/email on all plans; regional phone lines (US/Canada, UK, Australia, Spain, Italy); 90% CSAT claimed. Onboarding support is excellent, but a recurring complaint is that quality "drops to zero" once issues reach the technical team.
- Regional (APAC/Australia): Guesty has APAC presence via the HiRUM acquisition; Lodgify offers an Australia phone line. Both serve EU and US time zones.
#6. Customer Reviews & Real User Experience
#Review-score table (as of July 2026)
Review scores by platform
Axis starts at 3.0 to show the spread, not at zero.
| Platform | Lodgify | Guesty |
|---|---|---|
| Trustpilot | 4.8★ (~2,760-3,900 reviews) | 4.5★ (~1,000-1,430 reviews) |
| Capterra | 4.5★ (~1,282-1,311) | 4.4★ (~462-480) |
| Capterra sub-scores | Ease 4.4 · Support 4.6 · Features 4.4 · Value 4.3 | Ease 4.4 · Support 4.3 · Features 4.4 · Value 4.2 |
| G2 | ~4.2★ (56-66 reviews) | ~4.6★ (64-84 reviews) |
| GetApp | 4.5★ (~1,282) | 4.4★ (~337) |
| Guesty Lite (Capterra, ex-Your Porter) | N/A | 4.7★ (~547) |
| App Store / Google Play | 4.1★ / 4.7★ | 4.1★ / 3.2★ |
| PissedConsumer | 1.8★ (13 reviews, small sample) | N/A |
Note the small-sample skew: Guesty scores higher on G2 (a smaller, more technical audience), while Lodgify dominates on high-volume consumer sites like Trustpilot/Capterra. Many Lodgify and Guesty reviews are vendor-invited with incentives ("Vendor Referred, Incentive Offered"), which inflates positive volume on both.
#Lodgify: common praise
- Direct-booking website builder and channel centralization (users report 40-75% of bookings shifting to direct).
- Ease of use and time saved; strong free onboarding (specialists named repeatedly).
- Good value for single/small hosts; AI messaging praised.
#Lodgify: common complaints
- Channel sync reliability (Airbnb/Booking.com) is the most consistent negative theme, with double bookings and financial discrepancies at larger portfolios (one 150-unit operator reported Booking.com sync failures).
- Billing & cancellation: auto-renewal without warning, refusal of pro-rated refunds after cancellation, refund refusals after the 14-day window. BBB and PissedConsumer show billing-dispute patterns (small samples but consistent themes).
- Reporting gaps (no cleaning/linen/maintenance cost capture); PM modules and guest app called "nearly worthless" by some.
- Support escalation drops in quality once past onboarding.
#Guesty: common praise
Comprehensive one-stop platform; excellent automation and message templating; strong channel manager; named CSMs praised (Hazel, Alexandra, Or, etc.); frequent feature releases.
#Guesty: common complaints
- Cost and quote opacity is the #1 complaint.
- Billing disputes are recurring and structural: a BBB complaint documents being billed for 17 vs. 9 listings and charged $50 vs. contracted $45 for Guesty Shield ($2,564.96 in disputed charges); Trustpilot users report being charged before agreed start dates and multiple incorrect charges (one ~$700 CAD); "constant battle with billing."
- Auto-renewal / contract rigidity: annual auto-renewal "without clear communication," inability to downgrade mid-contract; a "gap between sales promises and the superseding contract."
- Bugs/glitches affecting daily operations; accounting/trust-accounting module "clunky"; API reliability issues with poorly announced updates.
- Support escalation slow for complex issues.
- Overkill for small hosts.
#Switching stories
- Guesty's own (vendor-supplied) study of 724 US PMs (<20 listings, 2022-2024) claims +17% revenue per listing and +24.6% portfolio growth after switching to Guesty from Lodgify/Hostaway/etc. Treat as marketing.
- Independent reviews and forums show movement in both directions: hosts leaving Guesty for Hospitable (simpler, cheaper messaging) after billing/contract frustration; and a Lodgify review noting a customer who came to Lodgify from Guesty citing channel-mapping issues. Consensus among independent operators: Lodgify for direct-booking small hosts, Guesty (or Hostaway) once you scale past ~15-20 units.
#7. Strengths & Weaknesses: Honest Verdict
Where Lodgify clearly wins: direct-booking website builder; pricing transparency; lower cost at every SMB size; free onboarding; ease of use; higher-volume positive review base; consumer app ratings.
Where Guesty clearly wins: channel breadth (60+ direct API); automation depth; trust accounting & owner portal; open API & integration marketplace; multi-unit/hotel inventory; enterprise scalability; 24/7 phone support infrastructure; native dynamic pricing + AI revenue agent.
Roughly equal: unified inbox/messaging; native dynamic pricing (both now Beyond-powered on Lodgify's side); guest screening via integrations; AI messaging assistants.
Deal-breakers:
- Lodgify: sync reliability at scale (15+ units); rigid refund policy; thin reporting; not built for 100+ multi-owner operations.
- Guesty: opaque quote-only pricing; onboarding fees; annual auto-renewal + no mid-contract downgrade; recurring billing disputes; overkill and overpriced for 1-5 listings.
#8. Best-Fit Buyer Matrix
| Buyer profile | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| 1-2 properties | Lodgify (or Hospitable/Guesty Lite if messaging-only) |
| 3-10 properties | Lodgify for direct-booking focus; Hostaway/Guesty if automation-heavy |
| 10-25 properties | Tossup: Lodgify on budget; Guesty/Hostaway if you need accounting/owner portal |
| 25-100 properties | Guesty (or Hostaway) |
| 100+ / enterprise / multi-brand | Guesty Enterprise |
| Individual host | Lodgify |
| Professional PM / management company (multi-owner) | Guesty (trust accounting, owner portal) |
| Co-host / small management | Lodgify or Hostaway |
| Hotel / aparthotel | Guesty (Kigo/HiRUM heritage) |
| Direct-booking-first strategy | Lodgify |
| OTA-heavy, max distribution | Guesty |
| Budget-conscious | Lodgify |
| Operations-heavy (cleaners/maintenance) | Guesty |
| Owners needing trust accounting/statements | Guesty |
| US market | Either |
| Europe | Either (both Barcelona-linked; Guesty via Kigo) |
| Australia/APAC | Guesty (HiRUM) |
| LATAM | Lodgify (Buenos Aires team) or Guesty |
#9. Alternatives Worth Considering
- Hostaway: the most-recommended scale alternative to both; 20,000+ PMs, ~4.8★ on Capterra/G2, deep automation, 200+ channels, strong support. Quote-only pricing. Often beats Lodgify on automation and Guesty on price/support. Commonly recommended instead of Guesty.
- Hospitable (ex-Smartbnb): best-in-class AI guest messaging, simple, cheap ($0 free tier, ~$29+/mo), published pricing. Best for Airbnb-heavy hosts. Commonly recommended instead of both for small hosts. Thin on accounting/owner statements.
- OwnerRez: top-rated (near 5★), excellent reporting/owner portal/accounting, US-focused, ~$40-88/mo, granular control but steeper setup. Best for finance-focused hosts. Strong owner statements.
- Smoobu: simple, affordable baseline for individual hosts.
- Uplisting, iGMS, Tokeet, Beds24: Beds24 is the budget/power-user pick (~$10/mo, highly configurable); iGMS strong automation; Uplisting clean multi-channel; Tokeet flexible.
- Escapia, Streamline, Track, Avantio: enterprise/vacation-rental-manager platforms competing with Guesty Enterprise, especially in the US (Streamline/Track) and Europe (Avantio).
#10. Migration & Switching Considerations
- Timeline: Budget 2-4 weeks per migration (listing rebuild, channel reconnection, template rewrites). Do not migrate during peak season.
- Risks: Airbnb/OTA re-linking can trigger disconnects; block calendars before migrating to avoid double bookings (a Lodgify migrant lost ~€2,000 by skipping this). Review history on direct sites doesn't port cleanly.
- Data portability: Export listing details, booking history, guest contacts, and financials before switching.
- Exit costs: Lodgify: annual plans may auto-renew; refunds often refused after 14 days; no pro-rating. Guesty: annual contracts with auto-renewal; downgrades wait until contract end; get onboarding fees and renewal escalators in writing before signing.
#11. FAQ
Is Guesty or Lodgify cheaper? Lodgify, at nearly every portfolio size, and its pricing is fully published ($14-62/mo per property). Guesty only publishes its $16/mo Lite tier; everything else is a sales quote.
Which is better for direct bookings? Lodgify. Its website builder is the category's strongest and includes free Google Vacation Rentals on higher tiers; Lodgify says these sites drive ~40% of bookings direct.
Which is better for large property managers? Guesty: trust accounting, owner portal, 60+ channels, open API, and enterprise scalability.
Does Lodgify charge booking fees? Capterra (July 2026) says all plans include 0% booking fees, but some independent trackers still cite a 1.9% fee on the Starter tier. Confirm at signup.
Does Guesty require a contract? Typically yes: annual with auto-renewal; you can upgrade anytime but can't downgrade until the term ends.
How many channels does each support? Guesty: 60+ direct API (plus hundreds via open API). Lodgify: ~5 direct API + iCal for others.
Is Guesty Lite the same as Guesty Pro? No. Lite (formerly Your Porter) is a separate, simpler product with its own help center; moving to Pro is effectively a migration.
Which has better support? Guesty has more infrastructure (24/7 phone across all tiers, 230-person team, CSMs); Lodgify has better onboarding. Both draw complaints about escalation of complex issues.
Which do Redditors/independent reviewers recommend? For 1-20 direct-booking-focused hosts, Lodgify or Hospitable; for scaling PMCs, Guesty or Hostaway.
#Caveats
- Pricing is a moving target. Guesty's Pro/Enterprise pricing and all add-ons are quote-only; the "$9 vs $16" contradiction is on Guesty's own page (verified July 27, 2026). Lodgify's tiers, prices, and even the Starter booking-fee question show live contradictions across sources. All figures are "as-of July 2026."
- Review scores vary by source and sample size. G2 samples are small (dozens); Trustpilot/Capterra are larger but include vendor-incentivized reviews on both sides. BBB/PissedConsumer samples are tiny but thematically consistent.
- Vendor claims are not independent. Guesty's "+17% revenue" and "500,000 properties," and Lodgify's "100,000 properties" and "40% direct bookings," are self-reported. Third-party customer/property counts for Lodgify conflict widely.
- Vendor comparison and revenue-boost content (including Guesty's "Guesty vs Lodgify" page, Lodgify's "Why Customers Choose Lodgify" page, and Hostaway's/Hospitable's comparison pages) is marketing and should be discounted accordingly.
Flat pricing, no commission, no sales call.
HostPort syncs Airbnb, Booking.com and Vrbo, runs your direct booking page and puts every guest message in one inbox. Free forever on iCal sync; $10 AUD per listing per month for two-way channel sync.